Balisage Paper: Raleigh’s Discoveries in the New World

New Insight into the Roanoke Colony

Introduction

On March 25, 1584, Queen Elizabeth I of England charged Sir Walter Raleigh to:

discover, search, find out, and view such remote, heathen and barbarous lands, countries, and territories, not actually possessed of any Christian Prince, nor inhabited by Christian People

Thorpe 1997

That same year Raleigh sent two captains, Philip Amades and Arthur Barlowe, from England to Hispaniola and the Canary Islands; from there, the captains were instructed to scout the lands northeast of those already claimed by Spain, to wit, Florida. This land — now encompassing the Carolinas and Virginia — was claimed on behalf of England and named Virginia, in honor of the Virgin Queen.

Securing a Permanent Colony in the Claimed Lands

With land claimed in the New World, an expedition was mounted to establish a settlement. The first expedition failed. Led by Sir Richard Grenville in April 1585, it encompassed 600 men of which 105 remained in the colony while Grenville returned to England for additional provisions. (See Appendix I.) However, when almost a year passed without Grenville’s return, the remainder of the expeditionary force took advantage of Sir Francis Drake’s arrival to seek return passage to England.[1]

The second expedition, organized by John White in 1587, fared better. It sailed with seven ships filled with Devon families intent upon establishing a colony in that part of Virginia called Roanoke, a word deriving from the speech of native peoples. (See Appendix II.) Two years after founding the Cittie of Raleigh, houses had been built for almost all families residing in the colony, and the colony had celebrated the birth of its first children born in the New World. The first child, grandchild of John White and child of Ananias and Eleanor Dare, was named Virginia in honor of the sovereign.

Native Inhabitants of the New World

Upon establishing the Roanoke colony, the settlers encouraged relations with the native inhabitants, of which there appear to have been a diverse group, including Croatans, Mangoaks, Chaonists, and Sequotanes, as well as Roanoke from which the region took its name. [Lane, Dunbar 1960] Not acquainted with native edibles, the colonists traded copper for grain and maize, as well as for leather and coral. It was also reported that natives assisted the settlers’ efforts to hunt game, fowl, and fish, although such efforts apparently failed to provide sufficient food stocks for the entire colony. [Lane]

Native Plants and Wildlife

The European settlers found the New World abundant with commodities known to yield victual and sustenance of man’s life. The first expeditionary force noted that a great variety of berries grew wildly, including raspberries, blueberries, and strawberries. Along with maize, native grain, which could be made into bread, grew in the area. Two other plants — more properly called roots — which could be saved for winter consumption were cassida and chyna. The settlers discovered that while some roots could be eaten much in appearance as they were dug, others had to be boiled before use as a foodstuff. As more fully described below, other plants included beans, and several crops previously unknown to the Europeans:

  • macocqwer (gourds),

  • melden (an herb),

  • planta solis (sunflower — used in a type of bread, as well as for broth),

  • peas (powdered in a mortar), and

  • potatoes.

Gourds

The native people grew a variety of large broad-leafed, ground-covering vines which produced what they called macocqwer or gourds. (See Figure 1.) Varying in color among shades of green, yellow, and orange, these gourds served a number of functions, not chief of which was as a food source. There were two distinct types, soft-shelled and hard-shelled. Of particular interest to the settlers were pumpkins; grown throughout the summer, this gourd remained in the fields until late autumn’s frost. Following harvest, the gourd could be stored throughout the winter and its flesh made into stews.

Figure 1: Gourds

Colored drawing of five gourds, among which is a butternut squash 
            and a pumpkin

While gourds, pumpkins and squashes were new to the English, they were soon discovered to be very useful for warding off starvation.

However, far more important was the hard-skinned gourd. The value of this gourd lay not in its potential as a food source, but rather as a container and serving vessel. Once dried, these gourds were cut and hollowed for use as storage containers, as well as for bowls, ladles, cups, and other types of serving utensils. Indeed, since gourds grew in a variety of shapes and sizes, particular gourds could be selected for their resemblance to the items sought. For the adventurous, the durable objects could be carved and decorated with plant dyes.

Tomatoes

Also new to the colonists was the tomato, as shown in Figure 2. Tomatoes were described as thin-skinned succulent fruits with pulpy interiors. Almost Bristol red in color, the fruit was somewhat round in form and the size of a chicken’s egg — not anything approaching the size of modern, cultivated varieties. Of particular importance was the plant’s fecundity. The flowering, bush-like plant bore fruit over a period of months. Thus, a plant could produce as many as 15 tomatoes at a given time.

Figure 2: Tomatoes

Image description

Color drawing of two tomato vine segments; one vine shows four red tomatoes of varying sizes, while the other vine displays the plant’s yellow flowers.

Tomatoes were among the new fruits discovered in the New World.

Potatoes

Another root that proved beneficial was the potato. Similarly, to the cassida mentioned earlier, potatoes were considered roots rather than plants, as the edible portion of the plant lay underground. Given the curious nature of this legume, several examples were brought back from the New World. In fact, Raleigh attempted to cultivate the potato at his estate, Youghall, in Ireland.

Fruits and Nuts

The colony abounded with a wealth of fruits and nuts, some not previously known to the Europeans. In addition to mulberries, strawberries, and blueberries already mentioned, one of the more curious fruits found was called medlar by the natives. Medlar was a fruit not unlike cherries in size and color, but with a much sweeter taste. An equally unusual fruit was metaqvesvnnaqvk; notwithstanding its red fruit, that plant’s more important feature lay in the cochinile insects which fed upon its prickly thick leaves[2].

Equally abundant in variety and size were nuts. In addition to chestnuts and walnuts, the natives harvested no less than five types of acorns. These somewhat small nuts were either dried in a manner similar to that used in England for malt, or were boiled for broth.

Table I

North American Native Plants

Use Plant Part Examples
Vegetables
Seeds Corn
Beans
Fruits Squash
Peppers
Tomatoes
Roots Potatoes
Sweet Potatoes
Teas
Leaves Mountain Mint (Namewuskons)
Dawn Mint (Wabinowusk)
Berries Wintergreen

Information Processing

Information processing, especially text markup, was primitive in the colony. For example, most text stores were in XML! Documents may have looked like this:


<teiHeader>
  <fileDesc>
    <titleStmt>
      <title>Farming in the New World</title>
      ...
    </titleStmt>
  </fileDesc>
</teiHeader>
Notice the paired Tags: <title> and </title> and the primitive use of indenting. Unusual features of the colonists’ data processing practices included:

Tags

Meaningful descriptions of the information enclosed by the markers

Balance

All markup is both opened and closed (or explicitly empty)

Roanoke — a Failure?

But who shall dare

To measure loss and gain in this wise?

Defeat may be victory in disguise;

The lowest ebb is the turn of the tide.

— Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, from Loss and Gain (1848)

The Roanoke colony is conventionally regarded a failure. After returning to England in 1587 to secure additional provisions and armaments for the colony, John White returned to find the settlement deserted, its homes and buildings dismantled. To this day, the fate of the Roanoke settlers remains unknown. However, while the Roanoke colony did not flourish, it does merit its place in history. Raleigh’s efforts — along with those of countless other explorers to the New World — introduced New World plants such as potatoes and tomatoes to England, as described in section “Native Inhabitants of the New World”. But perhaps most important, the loss of Roanoke exposed the pitfalls in attempting to establish a settlement in a foreign environment. Those hard lessons may have made Jamestown’s later success in 1607 possible.

Appendix I. The First Expeditionary Force’s Colony, 1585-1586

Note

This Appendix contains an actual list of the individuals who sailed to the Roanoke Colony in 1585. (See Durant, David N., Raleigh’s Lost Colony, Appendix I, Atheneum, NY: 1981.)

  • Master Philip Amades, Admirall of the countrie

  • Master Hariot

  • Master Acton

  • Master Edward Stafford

  • Thomas Luddington

  • Master Marvyn

  • Master Gardyner

  • Captaine Vaughan

  • Master Kendall

  • Master Prideox

  • Robert Holecroft

  • Rise Courtney

  • Master Hugh Rogers

  • Thomas Foxe

  • Edward Nugent

  • Darby Glande

  • Edward Kelle

  • John Gostigo

  • Erasmus Clefs

  • Edward Ketcheman

  • John Linsey

  • Thomas Rottenbury

  • Roger Deane

  • John Harris

  • Frauncis Norris

  • Matthewe Lyne

  • Edward Kettell

  • Thomas Wisse

  • Master Thomas Harvie

  • Master Snelling

  • Master Anthony Russe

  • Master Allyne

  • Master Michel Polyson

  • John Cage

  • Thomas Parre

  • William Randes

  • Geffrey Churchman

  • William Farthowe

  • John Taylor

  • Philppe Robyns

  • Thomas Phillipes

  • Valentine Beale

  • James Skinner

  • George Eseven

  • John Chaundeler

  • Philip Blunt

  • Richard Poore

  • Robert Yong

  • Marmaduke Constable

  • Thomas Hesket

  • William Wasse

  • John Fever

  • Daniel

  • Thomas Taylor

  • Richard Humfrey

  • John Wright

  • Gabriell North

  • Robert Biscombe

  • William Backhouse

  • William White

  • Henry Potkin

  • Dennis Barnes

  • Joseph Borges

  • Doughan Gannes

  • William Tenche

  • Randall Latham

  • Thomas Hulme

  • Walter Myll

  • Richard Gilbert

  • Steven Pomarie

  • John Brocke

  • Bennet Harrye

  • James Stevenson

  • Charles Stevenson

  • Christopher Lowde

  • Jeremie Man

  • James Mason

  • David Salter

  • Richard Ireland

  • Thomas Bookener

  • William Philippes

  • Randall Mayne

  • Bennet Chappell

  • Richard Sare

  • James Lasie

  • Smolkin

  • Thomas Smart

  • Robert

  • John Evans

  • Roger Large

  • Humfrey Garden

  • Frauncis Whitton

  • Rowland Griffyn

  • William Millard

  • John Twyt

  • Edwarde Seklemore

  • John Anwike

  • Christopher Marshall

  • David Williams

  • Nicholas Swabber

  • Edward Chipping

  • Sylvester Beching

  • Vincent Cheyne

  • Haunce Walters

  • Edward Barecombe

  • Thomas Skevelabs

  • William Walters

Appendix II. The Roanoke Colony, 1587

Note

This Appendix contains an actual list of the individuals who sailed to the Roanoke Colony in 1587, as well as the names of children born at the colony. (See Durant, David N., Raleigh’s Lost Colony, Appendix I, Atheneum, NY: 1981.)

  • Men

    • John White [Governor]

    • Roger Bailie [Assistant]

    • Ananias Dare [Assistant]

    • Christopher Cooper [Assistant]

    • Thomas Stevens [Assistant]

    • John Sampson [Assistant]

    • Dyonis Harvie [Assistant]

    • Roger Prat [Assistant]

    • George Howe [Assistant]

    • Simon Fernando [Assistant]

    • William Willes

    • John Brooke

    • Cutbert White

    • John Bright

    • Clement Tayler

    • William Sole

    • John Cotsmur

    • Humfrey Newton

    • Thomas Colman

    • Thomas Gramme

    • Nicholas Johnson

    • Thomas Warner

    • Anthony Cage

    • John Jones

    • John Tydway

    • Ambrose Viccars

    • Edmond English

    • Thomas Topan

    • Henry Berrye

    • Richard Berrye

    • John Spendlove

    • John Hemmington

    • Thomas Butler

    • Edward Powell

    • John Burden

    • James Hynde

    • Thomas Ellis

    • William Browne

    • Michael Myllet

    • Thomas Smith

    • Richard Kemme

    • Thomas Harris

    • Richard Taverner

    • John Earnest

    • Henry Johnson

    • John Starte

    • Richard Darige

    • William Lucas

    • Arnold Archard

    • John Wright

    • William Dutton

    • Morris Allen

    • William Waters

    • Richard Arthur

    • John Chapman

    • William Clement

    • Robert Little

    • Hugh Tayler

    • Richard Wildye

    • Lewes Wotton

    • Michael Bishop

    • Henry Browne

    • Marke Bennet

    • John Gibbes

    • John Stilman

    • Robert Wilkinson

    • Peter Little

    • John Wyles

    • Brian Wyles

    • George Martyn

    • Hugh Pattenson

    • Martyn Sutton

    • John Farre

    • John Bridger

    • Griffen Jones

    • Richard Shaberdge

    • James Lasie

    • John Cheven

    • Thomas Hewet

    • William Berde

    • Henry Rufoote

    • Richard Tomkins

    • Henry Dorrell

    • Charles Florrie

    • Henry Mylton

    • Henry Payne

    • Thomas Harris

    • William Nicholes

    • Thomas Phevens

    • John Borden

    • Thomas Scot

  • Women

    • Elyoner Dare

    • Margery Harvie

    • Agnes Wood

    • Wenefrid Powell

    • Joyce Archard

    • Jane Jones

    • Elizabeth Glane

    • Jane Pierce

    • Audry Tappan

    • Alis Chapman

    • Emme Merrimoth

    • Colman

    • Margaret Lawrence

    • Joan Warren

    • Jane Mannering

    • Rose Payne

    • Elizabeth Viccars

  • Children

    • John Sampson

    • Robert Ellis

    • Ambrose Viccars

    • Thomas Archard

    • Thomas Humfrey

    • Tomas Smart

    • George Howe

    • John Prat

    • William Wythers

  • Children Born at the Colony

    • Virginia Dare

    • Harvye

  • Native Peoples (who having been in England returned to the colony)

    • Manteo

    • Towaye

References

[Borio 1954] Borio, Gene. Smoking in England — Elizabethan, excerpted from Alfred H. Dunhill’s The Gentle Art of Smoking. [online]. Library of Congress catalog card #54-10495 (1954). The Tobacco BBS [cited 20 May 1998]. http://www.tobacco.org/History/Elizabethan_smoking.html.

[XML 1.0 Recommendation] Bray, Tim, Jean Paoli, C. M. Sperberg-McQueen, Eve Maler, François Yergeau. eds. Extensible Markup Language (XML) 1.0 (Fifth Edition). W3C Recommendation 26 November 2008. http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-xml/.

[DeFord 1997] DeFord, Susan. Tobacco: The Noxious Weed That Built a Nation, Special to The Washington Post (May 14, 1997) at H01. [online]. © 1997 [cited 29 May 1998]. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp~srv/intereact/longterm/horizon/051497/tobacco.htm.

[Dickerson 1997] Dickerson, George. Beyond Turkey: Corn Shaped History, Cuisines. [online]. Ed. D’Lyn Ford. New Mexico State University College of Agriculture & Home Economics, 11 Nov 1997 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://elroy.nmsu.edu/CAHE/press/corn_history1997.html.

[Dunbar 1960] Dunbar, Gary S. The Hatteras Indians of North Carolina. Ethnohistory 7, no. 4 (Autumn 1960): 410–418. doi:https://doi.org/10.2307/480877.

[Settlement] First English Settlement in the New World. [online]. [cited 13 Apr1998]. http://hal.dcr.state.nc.us/nc/ncsites/English1.htm#First.

[Griffith 1998] Griffith, Kelley. The Literary Treatment of Virginia Dare. Presented at Roanoke Colonization: An Interdisciplinary Conference, Manteo, NC, September 10-11, 1998.

[Lane] Lane, Ralph. The Colony at Roanoake — 1586. [online]. [cited 13 Apr 1998]. http://www.nationalcenter.inter.net/ColonyofRoanoke.html.

[Tobacco] Part 2. The Story of the Arrival and First Uses of Tobacco in Europe, in The History of Tobacco. [online]. [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.tobacco.co.uk/library/history.html#part2.

[Prindle 1996a] Prindle, Tara. Indian Corn, excerpted from Teaching about Thanksgiving. [online]. Fourth World Documentation Project. Native American Technology and Art. © 1996 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.lib.uconn.edu/NativeTech/cornhusk/cornfwdp.html.

[Prindle 1996b] Prindle, Tara. Native American History of Corn. [online]. Native American Technology and Art. © 1996 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.lib.uconn.edu/NativeTech/cornhusk/cornhusk.html.

[Stick 1983] Stick, David. Roanoke Island: The Beginnings of English America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1983.

[Thorpe 1997] Thorpe, Francis Newton, ed. Charter to Sir Walter Raleigh: 1584, in The Federal and States Constitutions, Colonial Charters, and Other Organic Laws of the States, Territories, and Colonies Now or Heretofore Forming the United States of America (compiled under Act of Congress of June 30, 1906). [online]. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1909. The Avalon Project. Co-Dir. William C. Fray & Lisa A. Span. © 1997 [cited 8 Apr 1998]. http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/raleigh.htm.

[ICW-Net 1998] Virginia Dare, in Tales from the Coast! [online]. ICW-NET © 1998 [cited 13 Apr 1998]. http://www.outerbanks-nc.com/manteo/history/vadare.htm.



[1] It has been argued that the first expedition was not a failure. Richard Grenville did return to the colony with additional provisions not long after Drake’s departure, and he ordered 15 men, supposedly supplied for two years, to remain in the colony while he returned for new settlers. However, it is unknown whether these men were present to greet the subsequent expedition.

[2] In the 16th century, such insects were prized in the making of a vibrant red dye.

×

Borio, Gene. Smoking in England — Elizabethan, excerpted from Alfred H. Dunhill’s The Gentle Art of Smoking. [online]. Library of Congress catalog card #54-10495 (1954). The Tobacco BBS [cited 20 May 1998]. http://www.tobacco.org/History/Elizabethan_smoking.html.

×

Bray, Tim, Jean Paoli, C. M. Sperberg-McQueen, Eve Maler, François Yergeau. eds. Extensible Markup Language (XML) 1.0 (Fifth Edition). W3C Recommendation 26 November 2008. http://www.w3.org/TR/REC-xml/.

×

DeFord, Susan. Tobacco: The Noxious Weed That Built a Nation, Special to The Washington Post (May 14, 1997) at H01. [online]. © 1997 [cited 29 May 1998]. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp~srv/intereact/longterm/horizon/051497/tobacco.htm.

×

Dickerson, George. Beyond Turkey: Corn Shaped History, Cuisines. [online]. Ed. D’Lyn Ford. New Mexico State University College of Agriculture & Home Economics, 11 Nov 1997 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://elroy.nmsu.edu/CAHE/press/corn_history1997.html.

×

Dunbar, Gary S. The Hatteras Indians of North Carolina. Ethnohistory 7, no. 4 (Autumn 1960): 410–418. doi:https://doi.org/10.2307/480877.

×

First English Settlement in the New World. [online]. [cited 13 Apr1998]. http://hal.dcr.state.nc.us/nc/ncsites/English1.htm#First.

×

Griffith, Kelley. The Literary Treatment of Virginia Dare. Presented at Roanoke Colonization: An Interdisciplinary Conference, Manteo, NC, September 10-11, 1998.

×

Lane, Ralph. The Colony at Roanoake — 1586. [online]. [cited 13 Apr 1998]. http://www.nationalcenter.inter.net/ColonyofRoanoke.html.

×

Part 2. The Story of the Arrival and First Uses of Tobacco in Europe, in The History of Tobacco. [online]. [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.tobacco.co.uk/library/history.html#part2.

×

Prindle, Tara. Indian Corn, excerpted from Teaching about Thanksgiving. [online]. Fourth World Documentation Project. Native American Technology and Art. © 1996 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.lib.uconn.edu/NativeTech/cornhusk/cornfwdp.html.

×

Prindle, Tara. Native American History of Corn. [online]. Native American Technology and Art. © 1996 [cited 14 Apr 1998]. http://www.lib.uconn.edu/NativeTech/cornhusk/cornhusk.html.

×

Stick, David. Roanoke Island: The Beginnings of English America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1983.

×

Thorpe, Francis Newton, ed. Charter to Sir Walter Raleigh: 1584, in The Federal and States Constitutions, Colonial Charters, and Other Organic Laws of the States, Territories, and Colonies Now or Heretofore Forming the United States of America (compiled under Act of Congress of June 30, 1906). [online]. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1909. The Avalon Project. Co-Dir. William C. Fray & Lisa A. Span. © 1997 [cited 8 Apr 1998]. http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/raleigh.htm.

×

Virginia Dare, in Tales from the Coast! [online]. ICW-NET © 1998 [cited 13 Apr 1998]. http://www.outerbanks-nc.com/manteo/history/vadare.htm.

Author's keywords for this paper:
New World discoveries; American colonial history; English 16th century history